10 Surrogacy Myths: The Honest Truth About Becoming a Surrogate
Thinking about becoming a surrogate is a huge, life-changing decision. It’s a chance to give hope to a family who’s been dreaming of a baby, while also hitting some of your own financial goals.
But let’s be real—there’s a lot of weird info out there. If you’re between 20 and 39 and looking into this, you’ve probably heard some wild claims.
Here at Physician’s Surrogacy, we believe in being 100% upfront about what this journey really looks like. We aren’t just an agency; we’re the only physician-managed surrogacy program in the country. That means we look at every step through a medical lens to keep you safe.
This guide is here to bust the biggest myths and show you the truth about the surrogacy experience. We’ve broken everything down so you can see exactly what to expect, from the first needle to the final birth plan.
!
Top Myths About the Surrogacy Process
Now, let’s debunk the top myths about the surrogacy process.
Myth #1: The baby will be biologically related to the surrogate
This is probably the biggest thing people get wrong about modern surrogacy. In the past, “traditional” surrogacy was more common, where a surrogate used her own eggs. But today, that’s an antiquated practice.
The Reality of Gestational Surrogacy
In gestational surrogacy, which is the only type we offer, you have no genetic link to the baby. Here is how that works:
- An embryo is created in a lab using In Vitro Fertilization (IVF).
- This embryo uses the eggs and sperm from the intended parents or donors.
- Your own eggs are never involved in the process.
The embryo is placed directly into your uterus during a quick, 10-minute procedure called an embryo transfer. You are the “gestational carrier”—the amazing person who provides the home for the baby to grow, but the baby’s DNA is entirely separate from yours.
Myth #2: It’s too hard to “give the baby up” at the end
The phrase “giving the baby up” doesn’t really fit how surrogates feel. Most of the women we work with don’t see it as giving away their baby; they see it as giving a baby back to its parent.
Emotional Readiness and Screening
We take your mental health very seriously. Before you even sign a contract, you’ll go through a psychological evaluation. This helps make sure you’re emotionally ready for the unique journey of carrying a child for someone else.
- The “Babysitter” Mindset: Many surrogates describe the feeling as being a dedicated, long-term babysitter.
- Support System: We require you to have a strong support system at home.
- The Sisterhood: You’ll be part of our “Surrogacy Sisterhood,” connecting you with other women who totally get what you’re going through.
Myth #3: Surrogates are just doing it for the money
While the compensation is a massive benefit that can help you buy a house or pay off debt, it’s rarely the only reason women choose this path.
The Heart of Altruism
Most surrogates have an altruistic motive—they simply love being pregnant and want to help someone who can’t have a baby on their own.
- Helping Families: Many have seen friends or family struggle with infertility and feel a calling to help.
- Testimonials: Surrogates often say the emotional reward of seeing parents hold their baby for the first time is the most powerful part.
- Transparent Pay: We pay some of the highest rates in the industry, ranging from $55,000 to $75,000+. We’re also very transparent about how you get paid, using equal monthly installments so you can plan your family’s future, which is exactly how to ensure you are fully protected in the human trafficking vs paid surrogacy debate.
★
Myth #4: Surrogacy is risky and exploits women
Some people worry that surrogacy is dangerous or that agencies don’t care about the women involved. Because we are an OB-managed agency, your safety is actually our number one priority.
Why the OB-Managed Model Matters
Most agencies are run by former surrogates who understand the emotions but lack the medical background to handle complex pregnancies. We are different.
- Physician Oversight: Our in-house OB/GYN team monitors every stage of your journey.
- Antenatal Testing: We offer extra medical testing, like NIPT (Non-Invasive Prenatal Testing), that other agencies might skip. These tests check the baby’s health and give everyone peace of mind.
- Rigorous Requirements: We don’t just let anyone become a surrogate. You must have already had at least one healthy child and meet specific health markers like a BMI under 32. This makes sure your body is physically ready for another pregnancy.
If you’re asking yourself, “are you emotionally ready for surrogacy,” knowing you have a team of actual doctors managing your clinical care can relieve a massive amount of anxiety.
Myth #5: Surrogacy is basically the same as adoption
Surrogacy and adoption are two totally different legal and medical paths.
Legal Protections and Parentage
In surrogacy, legal contracts are signed before the pregnancy even begins.
- Birth Certificates: Your name will not be on the birth certificate; the intended parents have full legal rights from the start.
- Power of Attorney: We make sure all legal paperwork is in place well before the birth. This protects you from ever having to care for the baby if the parents aren’t there the moment it’s born.
- Independent Lawyers: You will have your own lawyer to represent your interests, and the parents pay for it. Independent representation ensures your rights are protected and prevents you from being scammed by a surrogacy agency.
Myth #6: You have to deliver the baby in San Diego
A lot of people think that because we are based in San Diego, you have to travel here to give birth. That’s a total myth.
Staying in Your Community
You will deliver the baby at a hospital near your own home.
- Local OB Care: Once you finish your first trimester, you are released to your own local OB doctor for the rest of the pregnancy.
- Limited Travel: You typically only need to travel once or twice at the very beginning for your medical screening and the embryo transfer.
- Paid Travel: The intended parents pay for all your travel costs, including hotels and meals.
Myth #7: The process is a total mess and takes years to start
The “traditional” surrogacy process can be frustratingly slow. Often, surrogates and parents wait 6 to 12 months just to find a match, only to have the medical screening fail later on.
The Truth About Our Medically Cleared Program
We’ve worked hard to fix the “black holes” in the timeline.
- The Medically Cleared Advantage: In our program, we review your medical records and clear you before you ever meet a set of parents. This means when you match, you are ready to move straight to the legal and transfer stages.
- One-Week Matching: Because we have the largest program in the nation, our average matching time is just one week.
If you want to dive deep into how our timeline works, check out our detailed surrogacy process guide to learn exactly how to choose a surrogacy agency as a surrogate based on timeline transparency.
Myth #8: You can’t be a surrogate if your tubes are tied
Believe it or not, you absolutely can!
How IVF Changes the Rules
Because there is a critical medical difference between gestational vs traditional surrogacy, your fallopian tubes aren’t needed at all.
- Direct Transfer: The embryo is placed directly into your uterus via IVF.
- Anatomy: As long as your uterus is healthy and you meet the other medical requirements, a tubal ligation doesn’t stop you from being a surrogate.
★
Myth #9: It’s going to cost me a lot of money to do this
Actually, being a surrogate should cost you zero dollars.
Zero-Cost Commitment
The intended parents handle every single expense related to the journey.
- Medical Bills: All your medical bills are paid for, including specialized surrogacy insurance.
- Lost Wages: If you have to miss work for appointments or recovery, we include stipends to cover those lost wages.
- Everyday Costs: We use a flat-rate compensation structure that covers things like mileage and childcare without you having to submit a million receipts.
Myth #10: I won’t have any say in who I carry for
Some women worry they’ll be forced into a match they don’t like. That couldn’t be further from the truth.
You Are in Control
The matching process is a two-way street.
- Your Preferences: We listen to exactly what you’re looking for—whether that’s a same-sex couple, a single parent, or a traditional family.
- Meet and Greets: You’ll have a video chat (or “meet and greet”) with the potential parents before anything is official.
- Final Say: You only move forward if you feel a genuine connection and comfort with the match.
The Reality of the Step-by-Step Process
While we have other pages that go deep into the nitty-gritty, here is a quick look at how we get from “maybe” to “baby”:
- Apply Online: A quick form to see if you meet the basic health and age rules.
- Initial Screening: We chat with you, check your medical records, and do a background check.
- Medical Clearance: Our OB team gives you the thumbs up so you’re ready to match.
- Matching: We find the perfect family and you have your first meeting.
- Legal Phase: Lawyers draft your contract while we manage all the details.
- The IVF Cycle: You start meds to get your body ready for the embryo.
- Pregnancy: You see your local doctors while we keep everyone updated.
- Delivery: The big day at your local hospital!
Want to see if you’re a fit? Take our pre-qualification quiz to find out instantly.
Your Journey to Changing a Life Starts Here
We’ve cleared up the myths, but the real magic is what happens next.
Here at Physician’s Surrogacy, we’re the nation’s only OB-managed agency, so you’ve got expert medical eyes on you from day one. We don’t leave you to figure things out alone; our coordinators are available 24/7 to be of service to your needs.
Plus, with our “medically cleared” model, you don’t have to deal with the long waits that slow down other programs.
Ready to see if you’re a fit?
Filling out our short application is the fastest way to find out if you meet the basic requirements and start this rewarding journey. It only takes a few minutes to take that first step toward a future that changes everything!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between gestational and traditional surrogacy?
In gestational surrogacy, the surrogate has no genetic link to the baby because the embryo uses donor or parent eggs. Traditional surrogacy uses the surrogate’s own eggs.
How are surrogates compensated?
Surrogates receive a fixed package of up to $55,000 to $75,000+, paid in monthly installments. This covers everything from your time to your health and family’s needs.
What happens if the first embryo transfer is not successful?
A failed transfer is a known risk in medicine. If it happens, our medical team reviews why and plans for the next attempt with the intended parents.
Who is responsible for medical decisions during the pregnancy?
Medical decisions are handled by you and the intended parents, with guidance from our OB-managed team. Everything is clearly outlined in your legal contract before you start.
What are the biggest challenges a surrogate might face?
Challenges include the physical demands of IVF meds, potential pregnancy complications, and the emotional work of carrying a baby for others. We offer 24/7 coordinator support to help.
How much contact do surrogates have with the intended parents after birth?
Post-birth contact is up to you and the parents. Some surrogates form lifelong friendships, while others prefer less contact once the baby is born.
Where does the surrogate give birth?
You will give birth at a local hospital in your own community, managed by your local OB doctor. You do not have to travel to San Diego to deliver.
Julianna Nikolic
Chief Strategy Officer Julianna Nikolic leads strategic initiatives, focusing on growth, innovation, and patient-centered solutions in the reproductive sciences sector. With 26+ years of management experience and a strong entrepreneurial background, she brings deep expertise to advancing reproductive healthcare.
